Profile
International Journal of Nursing & Clinical Practices Volume 5 (2018), Article ID 5:IJNCP-301, 4 pages
https://doi.org/10.15344/2394-4978/2018/301
Research Article
Effects of Oral Exercise on Oral Function among Japanese Dependent Elderly Individuals Living in Nursing Facilities

Naoko Morisaki

Himeji University, School of Nursing, Hyōgo, Japan
Dr. Naoko Morisaki, Himeji University, School of Nursing, 2042-2 Oshio, Himeji, Hyogo, 671-0101, Japan, Tel: +81-79-247-7357; E-mail: naoko_morisaki@koutoku.ac.jp
31 October 2018; 02 December 2018; 04 December 2018
Morisaki N (2018) Effects of Oral Exercise on Oral Function among Japanese Dependent Elderly Individuals Living in Nursing Facilities. Int J Nurs Clin Pract 5: 301. doi: https://doi.org/10.15344/2394-4978/2018/301
This study was funded by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research/ Basic Research (C) [No.16K12228] from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science.

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose is to clarify the relationship between oral exercise and oral function in dependent elderly patients in nursing facilities.
Methods: The subjects are dependent elderly people aged 65 years or older admitted to nursing facilities for elderly people in Japan. Dependent elderly people gathered for group oral exercises, with the guidance of medical welfare professionals, over 3 days a week, once a day, once for about 15 minutes. The exercises included were neck, shoulder, upper limb, tongue, lip, cheek movement, vocalization, deep breathing, and so on. Oral function was evaluated before oral exercises, 3 months after implementation, and 6 months after implementation. To evaluate oral function, tongue pressure and Oral Diadochokinesis (OD) were used.
Results: Before starting oral exercises, there were 62 participants; after 3 months there were 36, and after 6 months there were 25. The average value of tongue pressure prior to exercise was 22.52±9.44kPa; after 3 months it was 24.80±10.90kPa; after 6 months the value was 26.85±10.56kPa. OD’s /pa/ average value prior to exercise was 4.0±1.1 times per second; after three months the value was 4.2±1.2 times per second; after 6 months it was 5.3±3.6 times per second. The /ta/ value prior to exercise was 4.1±1.2 times per second; after 3 months the value was 4.1±1.2 times per second; after 6 months it was 5.4±3.6 times per second. The /ka/ value prior to exercise was 3.6±1.2 times per second; after 3 months the value was 3.8±1.0 times per second; after 6 months it was 4.7±3.2 times per second. Analysis of oral function evaluation values before and after oral exercises by corresponding one-way variance showed a significant increase in tongue pressure 6 months after oral exercises.
Conclusions: The results of the study suggest that oral exercise is effective in improving oral function in dependent elderly people. We think that it is necessary to continuously perform oral exercise with guidance by professionals to improve dependent elderly people’s oral function.


1. Introduction

Pneumonia is the third leading cause of death among all age groups in Japan, but yearly deaths from pneumonia are increasing particularly among the elderly. In 2016, 97.3% of pneumonia deaths were of people 65 and older; among those in long-term care pneumonia is the leading cause of death at 30%. In fact, it is said that most elderly deaths in nursing care facilities are a result of pneumonia. Many elderly pneumonia cases are caused by pulmonary aspiration, and the rate of cases of pulmonary aspiration increases with age [1]. In a nationwide study conducted by Yamasaki [2], 80% of pneumonia in patients 70 and older was found to be aspiration pneumonia.

Aspiration occurs when, owing to a decline in oral function, chewed food does not move smoothly from the pharynx to the stomach. From some previous studies [3], it is clear that declining oral function among the elderly is a primary factor leading to severe conditions such as pneumonia, and it is closely related to health prognosis.

Oral function is a key body function, so its efficacy decreases with age. In recent years, efforts to maintain or improve oral function among elderly people are spreading in Japan. Oral exercises are used as a general approach with dependent elderly people. The oral cavity consists of many muscles which can be trained by oral exercise, so theoretically the muscles around the oral cavity can be strengthened as well. Thus, it is thought that oral exercises can maintain and improve oral function. Currently, they are widely used as preventive nursing care in Japan. However, current evidence for the effect of oral exercise is insufficient. Therefore, in this study, we aim to clarify the impact of oral exercise on the oral function of dependent elderly people.

2. Methods

Dependent elderly individuals were guided through oral exercises, and we investigated oral function before and after their implementation.

For our oral exercise methods, we consulted some previous studies which reported that effects could be expected [4]. Furthermore, we used exercises that elderly individuals could continue no matter their mental and physical condition, care personnel, caregivers’ burden, or other factors. Medical welfare professionals such as nurses, physiotherapists, caregivers, etc. conducted group exercise guidance for elderly subjects for about 15 minutes per day, once a day, at least 3 days a week (Figure 1). The exercises included neck, shoulder, and upper limb region movement forward and back and up and down, tongue area motion exercise, lip opening and closing motions, cheek inflation and deflation, vocal exercises, deep breaths, and the like. Oral function was evaluated before oral exercise, 3 months after exercise, and 6 months after exercise.

figure 1
Figure 1: Status of oral exercise.

2.1 Research subjects

The subjects of the survey were Japanese dependent elderly persons over 65 living in nursing facilities who, after reaching mutual understanding, consented to the study. Additionally, they were able to continue with the oral exercise regimen. Furthermore, the nursing facility that conducted this survey is positioned as an intermediate facility for medical care and welfare, and the average number of days for elderly people is about 100 days. After leaving the facility, the elderly patients move to one’s home or permanent residential welfare facility.

2.2 Survey items and evaluation methods

2.2.1 Basic status

We received information about subjects’ age, gender, and nursing care level from the host institution’s staff. In Japan nursing care is categorized into five levels. Level 1 indicates the lightest need for nursing care, and level 5 indicates the most serious need for care.

2.3 Oral functions

The following two items were examined: tongue pressure and oral diadochokinesis.

2.3.1 Tongue pressure

TPM-01, a tongue pressure measuring instrument (manufactured by JMS Co., Ltd., Hiroshima, Japan, Figure 2), was used to measure tongue pressure. This tongue pressure measuring instrument comprises a digital tongue pressure meter, connecting tube, and tongue pressure probe. The balloon section of the tongue pressure probe, which was automatically pressurized as predetermined by the measurement device, was inserted onto the oral part of the tongue while the participant was seated; the participant was instructed to elevate the tip of the tongue to the palate at a maximum force for 5 to 7 seconds, during which the intensity of the force that crushed the balloon was measured. The tongue pressure measurement was performed twice consecutively in accordance with the method described in previous studies [5], and the mean of the measured values was recorded as the tongue pressure level (kPa). Elderly adults aged 70 years or older are considered to require a tongue pressure level of 20 kPa or greater [5].

figure 2
Figure 2: States of tongue pressure.

2.3.2 Oral diadochokinesis

Oral Diadochokinesis (OD) was used. OD is regarded by Japan’s Preventive Care Project’s oral function improvement program as an indicator of articulation function. Participants are asked to alternately repeat “pa/ta/ka” syllables as quickly as possible, and the frequency of utterances is assessed. For measurement, an automatically counting OD-measuring instrument called Kenkou-kun (manufactured by Takei Scientific Instruments) was used [6]. Five second intervals of vocalization were performed in a quiet room, and from that five second interval a one-second average utterance rate was calculated.

2.4 Data analysis

Before oral exercise was implemented, after 3 months, and after 6 months, associations with the oral functions were analyzed using a paired one-way analysis of variance. The significance level was set to less than 0.05. The statistical software IBM SPSS Ver. 25.0 was used for the statistical analyses.

2.5 Ethical considerations

This study was conducted after obtaining consent from the participants as well as from individuals affiliated with the surveyed facilities; the following were fully explained to the participants and affiliated individuals: the study purpose, procedure, optional nature of study participation, protection of personal information, and results publication.

In addition, the survey in this study was conducted after obtaining approval from the Research Ethics Review Committee of the School of Nursing at the Himeji University (2016-N005).

3. Results

3.1 Basic attributes (Table 1)

There were 62 subjects (19 males and 43 females) before starting oral exercises, average age 82.7 ± 7.9 years old. Among them, 29 (46.8%) required nursing care of level 1 to 2, and 33 (53.2%) required care level 3 to 5. After 3 months, the number of subjects was 36 (12 males, 24 females), average age 84.5 ± 5.9 years old. Among them, 14 (38.9%) required nursing care level 1 to 2, and 22 (61.1 %) required care level 3 to 5. After 6 months, the number of subjects was 25 (9 males, 16 females), average age 84.0± 6.4 years old. Among them, 11 (44.0%) required nursing care level 1 to 2, and 14 (56.0 %) required care level 3 to 5.

table 1
Table 1: Basic status of research subjects.

3.2 Oral functions

Tongue pressure values before oral exercise, after 3 months, and after 6 months are shown (Table 2).

table 2
Table 2: Oral functions of research subjects.

3.3 Tongue pressure

Average tongue pressure before exercises was 22.52±9.44kPa, and 20 participants (32.3%) did not achieve a force of 20kPa, which is considered a standard value for those aged 70 years or older.

The average after three months was 24.80±10.90kPa, and 11 participants (30.6%) did not achieve a force of 20kPa. The average after six months was 26.85±10.56kPa, and 8 participants (32%) did not achieve a force of 20kPa.

3.4 Oral diadochokinesis

The average /pa/ value prior to exercise was 4.0±1.1 times per second; after three months the average was 4.2±1.2 times per second; after six months the average was 5.3±3.6 times per second.

The average /ta/ value prior to exercise was 4.1±1.2 times per second; after three months the average was 4.1±1.2 times per second; after six months the average was 5.4±3.6 times per second.

The average /ka/ value prior to exercise was 3.6±1.2 times per second; after three months the average was 3.8±1.0 times per second; after six months the average was 4.7±3.3 times per second.

3.5 Analysis of oral function before and after oral exercise

Oral function evaluation values before oral exercises, after 3 months, and after 6 months were analyzed using a one-way analysis of variance corresponding to each tongue pressure value and each OD value. There was a significant difference between tongue pressure values before and after oral exercise (p less than 0.05, Table 3), but no significant difference was found in any OD value.

table 3
Table 3: Analysis of Tongue pressure before and after Oral exercise.

4. Discussion

4.1 Current oral functions among dependent elderly persons living in nursing facilities

In this study, the present condition of oral function of elderly patients needing primary nursing care admitted to nursing rehabilitation facilities was clarified by assessing tongue pressure and articulation function.

Although tongue pressure is the force required to send chewed food to the pharynx at the time of swallowing, it is reported that the decrease in the tongue pressure of the elderly also affects chewing function [7] and meal form [8].

Among these subjects, about 30% did not reach 20kPa [5], which is a measure of tongue pressure over the age of 70 years, and there is concern about potential adverse effects on aspiration.

As for OD, compared with a study of 218 people receiving home nursing care (/pa/ 4.9±1.5 times per second, /ta/ 4.8±1.4 times per second, /ka/ 4.5±1.3 times per second) [9], the value before oral exercise as well as three months after starting were low.

From these results, it is clear that there are considerable numbers of elderly persons who suffer oral function deterioration entering nursing facilities. The oral function of dependent elderly people is not only a physical health issue but is also related to Quality of Life [10], so we believe it is necessary to actively take some approach to maintain or improve oral function.

4.2 Association between oral functions and oral exercise

Based on previous studies, oral exercises in this study were made into methods that can be implemented at facilities. After 3-month and 6-month intervals of oral exercise, we assessed oral function using tongue pressure and OD. The tongue is a power source that moves the food taken into the oral cavity onto the teeth and mixes the crushed and milled food with saliva to form a bolus [11], accomplishing an important role in the feeding process. It is thought that the amount and strength of the tongue muscles decreases in the elderly [12,13], and the tongue pressure value also decreases accordingly. In this study, we observed a significant increase in tongue pressure after oral exercise.

Therefore, our study suggests that oral exercise is effective in improving tongue pressure. While no significant difference was observed in the tongue pressure value after 3 months, nevertheless a significant difference was confirmed after 6 months. For that reason, in order to prevent deterioration in tongue pressure due to aging, we believe that a continuous long-term effort of about 6 months is necessary.

Regarding OD, there was no significant difference observed after oral exercises. Accordingly, improvement on articulation function among dependent elderly patients from a 3-month period of oral exercise is considered weak. However, when comparing the average value of each OD before and after oral gymnastics, an increase in the value is observable, so upon reassessing the methods and so forth, we think we can expect such results.

Previous studies have revealed that the presence or absence of exercise for tongue movement and lip movement among oral exercise is related to OD [9]. Therefore, we think that there is a possibility that the articulation function improves by strengthening the tongue movement and lip movement.

Competing Interests

The author declare that there is no competing interests regarding the publication of this article.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to express their heartfelt gratitude to all personnel involved with the nursing facility that collaborated in this study, as well as the dependent elderly persons who participated in the surveys.


References

  1. Fukuoka Y, Hatakeyama R, Hatakeyama A, Sato A, Sasaki H (2006) Oral care and dysphagia pneumonia. Antibiotics & Chemotherapy 22: 602-606
  2. Yamawaki M (2009) Epidemiology of dysphagia pneumonia. Sogo Rihabiriteshon 37: 105-109
  3. Kikuchi R, Watabe N, Konno T, Mishina N, Sekizawa K, et al. (1994) High incidence of silent aspiration in elderly patients with community-acquired pueumonia. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 150: 251-253 [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  4. Naoko M (2016) Effective oral exercise for the elderly - from literature review. Japanese Society of Human Care Research 8:97-102
  5. Tsuga K, Yoshida M, Urabe H, Hayashi R, Yoshikawa M, et al. (2004) Effect of general condition and tongue pressure on meal form selection for elderly care recipient. Journal of Japanese Society for Masticatory Science and Health Promotion 14: 62-67 [CrossRef]
  6. Ito K, Yoshihara A, Takano N, Ishigami K, SeidaY, et al. (2009) A comparison of methods for the measurement of Oral diadochokinesis 24: 48-54 [CrossRef]
  7. Kikutani T, Tamura F, Nishiwaki K, Kodama M, Suda M, et al. (2009) Oral motor function and masticatory performance in the community-dwelling elderly. Odontology 97: 38-42 [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]
  8. Tsuga K, Yoshida M, Urabe H, Hayashi R, Yoshikawa M, et al. (2004) Effect of general condition and tongue pressure on meal form selection for elderly care recipient. Journal of Japanese Society for Masticatory Science and Health Promotion 14:62-67 [CrossRef]
  9. Naoko M, Hiroko M, Yoshie U (2015) Relationship between the articulation function and oral exercise among community-dwelling dependent older individuals. - A survey using Oral diadochokinesis. Journal of the Japan Nursing Association - Health Promotion45:155-158
  10. Morisaki N (2017) Relationship between swallowing functions and healthrelated quality of life among community-dwelling dependent older individuals. Jpn J Nurs Sci 14: 353-363 [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  11. Hiiemae KM, Palmer J (1999) Food transport and bolus formation during complete feeding sequences on foods of different initial consistency. Dysphagia 14: 31-42 [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  12. Price PA, Darvell BW (1981) Force and mobility in the ageing human tongue. Med J Aust 1: 75-78 [CrossRef] [Google Scholar] [PubMed]
  13. Bässler R (1987) Histopathology of different types of atrophy of the human tongue. Pathol Res Pract 182: 87-97 [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]